Forex Muse vs. RSS

[d3m0nz3y3]

This thread is created so i can pass on my honest opinions about the comparison between the two services. Anyone else who uses these or SNW can post his/her thoughts as well. I was getting alot of PM's about this, so i thought i would just start a thread so all can keep up with how things are going. I will try to compare as many trades as i can for the next two weeks, and if possible post videos aswell. One last IMPORTANT NOTE, since muse doesnt have a log file, i cannot compare the exact time as to how fast either one was. If i say RSS/MUSE was 3 seconds faster, this means it was ~3 secs faster. Hope i said everything...
Good Luck
d3

[Compujock]

Thanks d3. This will be very helpful and videos would be just great!

[d3m0nz3y3]

Muse was once again a little bit faster on the AUD Interest Rate. However i was not at my desk so the recording is one hour long and i dont know how to edit it :<.... i will try to post the video for the Trade Balance coming out in 15 minutes.

d3

[Compujock]

Originally Posted by d3m0nz3y3

Muse was once again a little bit faster on the AUD Interest Rate.
d3

Very interesting... On my computer RSS was just over 200ms faster then SNW, so that means Muse beat both of them on Aud Interest Rate!

[d3m0nz3y3]

Well one thing i will start doing is setting up rss on one broker and muse on another. I have just been using muse to auto click while the rss is just opened to see how fast/slow it is. Also, i will start paying attention to the voice from each service about no trade/sell/buy etc. Too late now, but i will post the video of the AUD Trade Balance tomorrow.
Happy 4th of July

d3

[Compujock]

Sounds good.

One thing that may be helpful in these videos would be to put a small digital software clock with millisecond readout on the screen somewhere, then we could get a somewhat accurate reading by pausing the video and noting the time when each clicker gets the numbers. Then we would know approximately how far apart RSS and the Muse are in milliseconds for each report.

[d3m0nz3y3]

Here is the video for the AUD Trade Balance.
www.teamgcc.com/aud_TB.avi
Let me know what stuff i need to add in here, apart from the clock with miliseconds on it.(if anyone knows of a clock let me know)

Thanks
d3

[Compujock]

Thanks for the video. It looked to me that RSS was just slightly faster then the Muse. Did it seem that way to you as well?

I had both SNW and RSS running on this one and for some reason RSS was very slow. SNW was a half second faster then RSS and it looked from the video that the Muse was some milliseconds slower then RSS. I need to start logging this information in an Excel spreadsheet so we can compare them for multiple releases over a period of several weeks. Unfortunately, I already canceled SNW, so someone else will have to provide us with the SNW/RSS speed comparison going forward. Maybe FrankTheTank can help out with that?

[d3m0nz3y3]

i didnt even notice until you pointed out. Yups looks like RSS a little bit faster. One more thing that came to my mind is that both the services click before they display the deviation/no trade/trade sign. From now on i will try to make both of them autuclick, so we can find out who actually clicked first instead of see'ing who displays the deviation/no trade/trade sign.

d3

[JEB]

Originally Posted by d3m0nz3y3

Here is the video for the AUD Trade Balance.
www.teamgcc.com/aud_TB.avi
Let me know what stuff i need to add in here, apart from the clock with miliseconds on it.(if anyone knows of a clock let me know)

Thanks
d3

I can't see the video are you using windows media player?
I heard "no trade" and I'm seeing ambience water. Could you tell me what is wrong?